Consumer Law Library

Mirror Industry

16 CFR Part 118 · Trade practice rules · in the Code of Federal Regulations 1966-1979 (13 annual editions)

Scanned CFR pages, OCR text may contain errors; the linked Library of Congress PDF is the authority. Not legal advice; not affiliated with the FTC. These rules and guides are historical: most were rescinded or replaced, so do not assume any is in force.

Latest edition: Library of Congress, 1979 CFR · Earliest edition: 1966 CFR

Text (1979 edition, OCR)

§ 62.3

Rebuilt
by an

Independent Rebuilder

(3) Disclosure that the product was
rebuilt by other than the manufactur-
er so identified as, for example:

Rebuilt
by other than

XYZ Motors

(4) Disclosure that the product was
rebuilt for the identified manufactur-
er, if such is the case, as for example:

Rebuilt
for

XYZ Motors
(Rule 2]

§ 62.3 Misrepresentation as to condition of
products and misuse of the terms “re-
built,” “factory rebuilt,” “remanufac-
tured,” etc.

(a) It is an unfair trade practice to
use, or cause or promote the use of,
any statement or representation in ad-
vertising, on containers, on industry
products, or elsewhere, which has the
capacity and tendency or effect of mis-
leading or deceiving purchasers or
prospective purchasers as to the condi-
tion of an industry product, or the
extent that an industry product has
been repaired or reconstructed.

(b) It is an unfair trade practice to
use the words “Rebuilt,” “Remanufac-
tured,” or words of similar import, as
descriptive of an industry product
which, since it was last subjected to
any use, has not been dismantled and
reconstructed as necessary, all of its
internal and external parts cleaned
and made free from rust and corro-
sion, all impaired, defective or sub-
stantially worn parts restored to a
sound condition or replaced with new,
rebuilt ‘ or unimpaired used parts, all
missing parts replaced with new, re-
built ' or unimpaired used parts, and
such rewinding or machining and
other operations performed as are nec-
essary to put the industry product in
sound working condition.

‘In accord with the provisions of this
paragraph (b).

Title 16—Commercial Practices

(c) It is an unfair trade practice to
represent an industry product as ‘“‘Fac-
tory Rebuilt” unless the product was
rebuilt as described in paragraph (b)
of this section at a factory generally
engaged in the rebuilding of such
products. (See also § 62.2) [Rule 3]

PART 118—MIRROR INDUSTRY

Sec.

118.0 Definitions.

118.1 Deception (general).

118.2 Misrepresentation of kind or type of
industry products.

118.3 Disclosure of foreign origin.

118.4 Disclosure of fact that products are
“rejects,” ‘“‘secornds,” etc.

118.5 Misrepresenting products as con-
forming to standard.

118.6 Deceptive pricing.

118.7 Deceptive use or imitation or simula-
tion of trade or corporate names, trade-
marks, etc.

118.8 False invoicing.

118.9 Guarantees, warranties, etc.

118.10 Substitution of products.

118.11 Commercial bribery.

118.12 Procurement of competitors’ confi-
dential information by unfair means and
wrongful use thereof.

118.13 Unfair threats of infringement
suits.

118.14 Inducing breach of contract.

118.15 Prohibited forms of trade restraints
(unlawful price fixing, etc.).

118.16 Prohibited discrimination.

118.17 Aiding or abetting use of unfair
trade practices.

Avutuortiry: Secs. 6, 5, 38 Stat. 721, 719; 15
U.S.C. 46, 45, unless otherwise noted.

Source: 27 FR 6213, June 30, 1962, unless
otherwise noted.

§ 118.0 Definitions.

As used in these rules the terms ‘“In-
dustry Member’ and “Industry Prod-
ucts” shall have the following mean-
ing:

(a) Industry member: Any person,
firm, corporation or organization (in-
cluding manufacturers, wholesalers,
jobbers, importers, retailers, etc.) en-
gaged in the manufacture, sale, offer-
ing for sale, or distribution of industry
products as defined below.

(b) Industry products. All kinds and
types of mirrors both utilitarian and
decorative.

(c) For the purposes of these rules
the following definitions shall apply:

350


Chapter !—Federal Trade Commission

Plate glass: A transparent glass, the two
surfaces of which are flat and parallel so
that they give clear and undistorted vision
and reflection, manufactured either by
floating hot glass in ribbon form upon a
heated liquid of greater density than that of
glass or by grinding and polishing a ribbon
of glass formed between two rolls.

Window glass: A transparent glass which
has been drawn or rolled, has glossy, fire
polished surfaces and a characteristic wavi-
ness of its surfaces which is visible when
viewed at an acute angle or in reflected
light. Window glass is sometimes referred to
in the industry as sheet or shock glass.

[27 FR 6213, June 30, 1962, as amended at
37 FR 18448, Sept. 12, 1972]

§ 118.1 Deception (general).

It is an unfair trade practice for any
industry member in connection with
the sale, offering for sale, or distribu-
tion of industry products to use any
advertisement '! or representation
which is false, or which by failure to
disclose material facts has the capac-
ity, tendency or effect. of misleading
purchasers or prospective purchasers
with respect to the type, grade, qual-
ity, quantity, use, size, design, materi-
al, finish, strength, backing, silvering,
thickness, composition, origin, prepa-
ration, manufacture, value, or distribu-
tion of any product of the industry, or
in any other material respect. [Rule 1]

§ 118.2 Misrepresentation of kind or type
of industry products.

It is an unfair trade practice for any
member of the industry to sell, offer
for sale, or distribute any industry
product under any representation or
circumstance having the capacity and
tendency or effect of misleading or de-
ceiving purchasers or prospective pur-
chasers in any respect with regard to
the kind or type of glass contained in
any industry product, or the kind or
type of backing affixed thereto.

(a) Misrepresentation as to kind or
type of glass. (1)(i) It is an unfair trade

'The word “advertisement” as here used
includes any written or verbal statement,
notice, presentation, illustration, or depic-
tion which directly or indirectly promotes
the sale of any industry product, or creates
an interest in the purchase of any such
product, whether same appears in a newspa-
per, magazine, catalog, letter, sales promo-
tional literature, radio or television broad-
cast, or in any other media.

$118.2

practice to sell, offer for sale, or dis-
tribute any industry product contain-
ing “window glass’ unless such prod-
uct is marked, labeled, or stamped so
as to reveal that the glass is ‘window
glass.”

(ii) The disclosure required by this
section must be made on the product
and be of such conspicuousness and
legibility as to readily come to the at-
tention of the casual observer, and of
such permanence, and so affixed, as to
remain on the product until consum-
mation of consumer sale thereof. Such
disclosure is not required upon indus-
try products 72 square inches or less in
size.

(2) In the sale, offering for sale, or
distribution of industry products, it is
an unfair trade practice to represent
that a product contains “crystal” or
“crystale” glass, when, contrary to the
representation, such product contains
a different glass, e.g., “plate glass’ or
“window glass.”

(3) In the sale, offering for sale, or
distribution of industry products it is
an unfair trade practice to represent
window glass as “distortion free,” or to
represent any other kind of glass as
“distortion free,’’ when such is not the
fact.

(4) In the sale, offering for sale, or
distribution of industry products it is
an unfair trade practice to describe
the glass contained in an industry
product as “shatter proof’ unless the
glass is so constituted or treated so as
in fact to prevent, in the event of
breakage, the shattering and dispersal
of particles of the glass.

(b) Misrepresentation as to backing.
(1) In the sale, offering for sale, or dis-
tribution of industry products it is an
unfair trade practice to represent that
an industry product is “copper
backed”, or is backed with ‘metallic
copper” or has a “copper electroplat-
ed’’ back, or to similarly use any other
word, term or legend of like import as
descriptive of the backing of an indus-
try product, unless the electroplating
of the copper backing is accomplished
by an electrolytic process.

NoTE: For the purposes of this part it is
established that both the “galvanic,” or
“contact” method, of electroplating (i.e., the
plating method using a self induced electric

351


§ 118.3

current), and the method using an external
source of current, are truly electroplating
processes. Both processes are equally well
defined by the definition of Electroplating
established by the American Society for
Testing Materials, as follows:

“Electroplating: The electro-deposition of
an adherent metallic coating upon an elec-
trode for the purpose of securing a surface
with properties or dimensions different
from those of the basic metal.”

No useful purpose can be served by attempt-
ing to establish a differentiation between
the mirror backing produced by these two
methods.

(2) Nothing in this section shall be
construed as prohibiting the use of
representations that any backing on
products of the industry contains
copper, which has been applied me-
chanically or by means other than the
use of electric current when such is
the fact, provided that a clear and con-
spicuous disclosure is made in conjunc-
tion with such representations as to
the manner of application of the back-
ing, as for example, “window glass
mirror, painted back.”

(3) The disclosure of the kind or
type of glass and the kind and type of
backing thereof required under this
section may be in the form of a stamp,
tag, mark or label on or attached to
the product and shall be of such size
type and so situated that it will come
to the attention of the casual observer
and be so affixed as to remain on the
product until consumption of consum-
er sale.

(4) The following are examples of
the marks, stamps or labels which will
be regarded as meeting the require-
ments of this section: An industry
product containing “plate glass,”
copper backed by an electrolytic proc-
ess may be marked or described “plate
glass-copper electroplated,” or “float
glass-copper backed”; an _ industry
product containing window glass
backed by an electrolytic process may
be marked or described ‘window glass-
copper plated back” or ‘‘sheet glass-
copper plated back,’ or an article con-
taining plate glass backed with a
copper plating which has been applied
mechanically or by means other than
the use of electric current may be
marked or described as “plate glass-
painted back.” [Rule 2]

Title 16—Commercial Practices

(27 FR 6213, June 30, 1962, as amended at
37 FR 18448, Sept. 12, 1972)

$118.3 Disclosure of foreign origin.

(a) It is an unfair trade practice to
misrepresent the country of manufac-
ture of industry products or their com-
ponents.

(b) It is also an unfair trade practice
to offer for sale, sell, or distribute any
industry product manufactured in a
foreign country, or any industry prod-
uct containing a substantial or materi-
al part manufactured in a foreign
country, without clear and adequate
disclosure of such fact, when the fail-
ure to make such disclosure has the
capacity and tendency or effect of mis-
leading or deceiving purchasers or
prospective purchasers.

(c) Disclosure of foreign origin as
and when required under paragraphs
(a) and (b) of this section, may be in
the form of a stamping or marking on
the product itself, or on a label or tag
securely attached to the product. Such
disclosure shall clearly identify the
foreign country in which the product,
or part thereof, was manufactured and
shall be of such conspicuousness as to
be noticeable and readable on casual
inspection and of such permanence as
to remain on the product until con-
summation of consumer sale.

Nore 1: Paragraph (b) of this section is
not to be construed as requiring disclosure
as to foreign manufacture or processing
when, by reason of further manufacturing
or processing operations in this country, or
merger with another part or other parts,
the imported product or part does not
retain the appearance and essential charac-
teristics which it possessed at the time of its
importation.

Note 2: Nothing in this section shall be
construed as relieving any member of the
industry (or other party) of the necessity of
complying with the requirements of the cus-
toms laws or regulations, or other applicable
provisions of law or regulation, relating to
marking of imported articles.

[Rule 3]

§ 118.4 Disclosure of fact that products
are “rejects,” “seconds,” etc.

An industry product not equaling
the manufacturer’s standard for his
first quality products shall not be rep-
resented as being of first quality and

352


Chapter |—Federal Trade Commission

shall be marked or labeled as being a
“second” or “reject,” or by some other
term which adequately makes known
the fact that it is not first quality.
Such disclosure shall be in the form of
a legible stamping or marking on the
product itself, or on a label or tag se-
curely attached to the product, and be
sufficiently conspicuous as to be likely
noticed and read on casual inspection
of the product, and be so placed on or
affixed to the product as to remain
thereon until consummation of con-
sumer sale. Disclosure that such prod-
ucts are “seconds” or “rejects,” shall
also be made in advertisements, price
lists, other sales promotional litera-
ture, and radio and television adver-
tisements relating to such products.
[Rule 4]

§ 118.5 Misrepresenting products as con-
forming to standard.

In the same, offering for sale, or dis-
tribution of industry products, it is an
unfair trade practice to represent,
through advertising or otherwise, that
such products conform to any stand-
ards recognized in or applicable to the
industry when such is not the fact.
[Rule 5]

§118.6 Deceptive pricing.

It is an unfair trade practice for any
member of the industry to represent
directly or indirectly in advertising or
otherwise that an industry product
may be purchased for a specified price,
or at a saving, or at a reduced price,
when such is not the fact; or otherwise
deceive purchasers or prospective pur-
chasers with respect to the price of
any product offered for sale; or fur-
nish any means or instrumentality by
which others engaged in the sale of in-
dustry products may make any such
representation.

Nore: On December 20, 1963 the Commis-
sion adopted Guides Against Deceptive Pric-
ing which became effective on January 8,
1964 and which supersede the Guides on
this subject as adopted October 2, 1958.
Copies of the Guides will be furnished upon
request.

[Rule 6]
(29 FR 7670, June 16, 1964]

§ 118.9

§ 118.7 Deceptive use or imitation or sim-
ulation of trade or corporate names,
trade-marks, etc.

It is an unfair trade practice for any
member of the industry:

(a) To imitate or simulate the trade-
marks, trade names, brands, or labels
of competitors, with the capacity and
tendency or effect of misleading or de-
ceiving purchasers or prospective pur-
chasers; or

(b) To represent by use of any trade
name, trade-marks, or other trade des-
ignation, that any industry member is
a manufacturer, wholesaler or import-
er when such is not the fact; or

(c) To use any trade name, corporate
name, trade-mark, or other trade des-
ignation, which has the capacity and
tendency or effect of misleading or de-
ceiving purchasers or prospective pur-
chasers as to the name, nature, or
origin of any product of the industry,
or of any material used therein, or
which is false, deceptive, or misleading
in any other material respect. [Rule 7]

§ 118.8 False invoicing.

Withholding from or inserting in in-
voices or sales slips any statements or
information by reason of which omis-
sion or insertion a false record is
made, wholly or in part, of the trans-
actions represented on the face of
suich invoices or sales slips, with the
capacity and tendency or effect of
thereby misleading or deceiving pur-
chasers, prospective purchasers, or the
consuming public in any material re-
spect, is an unfair trade practice.
[Rule 8]

$118.9 Guarantees, warranties, etc.

(a) Advertising of products shall not
contain representations that a product
is “guaranteed” without clear and con-
spicuous disclosure of:

(1) The nature and extent of the
guarantee, and

(2) Any material conditions or limi-
tations in the guarantee which are im-
posed by the guarantor, and

(3) The manner in which the guar-
antor will perform thereunder, and

(4) The identity of the guarantor.

(b) Guarantees shall not be used
which under normal conditions are im-
practical of fulfillment or which are

353


§ 118.10

for such a period of time or are other-
wise of such nature as to have the ca-
pacity and tendency of misleading pur-
chasers or prospective purchasers into
the belief that the product so guaran-
teed has a greater degree of servicea-
bility, durability or performance capa-
bility in actual use than in true in fact.
(Rule 9]

§ 118.10 Substitution of products.

It is an unfair trade practice for a
member of the industry to make unau-
thorized substitutions of products,
where such substitutions have the ca-
pacity and tendency or effect of mis-
leading or deceiving purchasers, by:

(a) Shipping or delivering industry
products which do not conform to
samples submitted, to specifications
(in bids or otherwise) upon which the
sale is consummated, or to representa-
tions made prior to securing the order,
without advising the purchaser of the
substitution and obtaining his consent
thereto prior to making shipment or
delivery; or

(b) Falsely representing the reason
for making substitutions. [Rule 10]

§ 118.11 Commercial bribery.

It is an unfair trade practice for a
member of the industry, directly or in-
directly, to give, or offer to give, or
permit or cause to be given, money or
anything of value to agents, employ-
ees, or representatives of customers or
prospective customers, or to agents,
employees, or representatives of com-
petitors’ customers or prospective cus-
tomers, without the knowledge of
their employers or principals, as an in-
ducement to influence their employers
or principals to purchase or contract
to purchase products imported, manu-
factured, or sold by such industry
member or the maker of such gift or
offer, or to influence such employers
or principals to refrain from dealing in
the products of competitors or from
dealing or contracting to deal with
competitors. [Rule 11)

§ 118.12 Procurement of competitors’ con-
fidential information by unfair means
and wrongful use thereof.

It is an unfair trade practice for any
member of the industry to obtain in-

Title 16—Commercial Practices

formation concerning the business of a
competitor by bribery of an employee
or agent of such competitor, by the
impersonation of one in authority, or
by any other unfair means, and to use
the information so obtained so as sub-
stantially to injure a competitor or un-
reasonably restrain trade. [Rule 12]

§118.13 Unfair threats of infringement
suits,

The circulation of threats of suit for
infringement of patents or trade-
marks among customers or prospective
customers of competitors, not made in
good faith but for the purpose and
with the effect of harassing or intimi-
dating such customers or prospective
customers, or of unduly hampering, in-
juring, or prejudicing competitors in
their business, is an unfair trade prac-
tice. [Rule 13]

§ 118.14 Inducing breach of contract.

(a) Knowingly inducing or attempt-
ing to induce the breach of existing
lawful contracts between competitors
and their customers, or between com-
petitors and their suppliers, or inter-
fering with or obstructing the per-
formance of any such contractual
duties or services, under any circum-
stance having the capacity and ten-
dency or effect of substantially injur-
ing or lessening competition, is an
unfair trade practice.

(b) Nothing in this section is intend-
ed to imply that it is improper to solic-
it the business of a customer of a com-
peting industry member; nor is the
section to be construed as in anywise
authorizing any agreement, under-
standing, or planned common course
of action by two or more industry
members not to solicit business from
the customers of either of them, or
from customers of any other industry
member. [Rule 14]

§ 118.15 Prohibited forms of trade re-
straints (unlawful price fixing, etc.). ‘

It is an unfair trade practice for any
member of the industry, either direct-

‘The prohibitions of this section are sub-
ject to Pub. L. 542, approved July 14, 1952—
66 Stat. 632 (the McGuire Act, commonly
referred to as the Fair Trade Amendment)

Footnotes continued on next page

354


Chapter I—Federal Trade Commission

ly or indirectly, to engage in any
planned common course of action, or
to enter into or take part in any un-
derstanding, agreement, combination,
or conspiracy with one or more mem-
bers of the industry, or with any other
person or persons, to fix or maintain
the price of any goods or otherwise
unlawfully to restrain trade; or to use
any form of threat, intimidation, or
coercion to induce any member of the
industry or other person or persons to
engage in any such planned common
course of action, or to become a party
to any such understanding, agreement,
combination, or conspiracy. [Rule 15]

§ 118.16 Prohibited discrimination.

(a) Prohibited discriminatory prices,
rebates, discounts, etc. It is an unfair
trade practice for any member of the
industry engaged in commerce, in the
course of such commerce, to grant or
allow, secretly or openly, directly or
indirectly, any rebate, refund, dis-
count, credit, or other form of price
differential, where such _ rebate,
refund, discount, credit, or other form
of price differential, effects a discrimi-
nation in price between different pur-
chasers of goods of like grade and
quality, where either or any of the
purchasers involved therein are in
commerce, and where the effect there-
of may be substantially to lessen com-
petition or tend to create a monopoly
in any line of commerce, or to injure,

Footnotes continued from last page

which provides that with respect to a com-
modity which bears, or the label or contain-
er of which bears, the trade-mark, brand, or
name of the producer or distributor of such
commodity and which is in free and open
competition with commodities of the same
general class produced or distributed by
others, a seller of such a commodity may
enter into a contract or agreement with a
buyer thereof which establishes a minimum
or stipulated price at which such commodity
may be resold by such buyer when such con-
tract or agreement is lawful as applied to in-
trastate transactions under the laws of the
State, Territory, or territorial jurisdiction in
which the resale is to be made or to which
the commodity is to be transported for such
resale, and when such contract or agree-
ment is not between manufacturers, or be-
tween wholesalers, or between brokers, or
between factors, or between retailers, or be-
tween persons, firms, or corporations in
competition with each other.

§ 118.16

destroy, or prevent competition with
any person who either grants or know-
ingly receives the berefit of such dis-
crimination, or with customers of
either of them: Provided, however,

(1) That the goods involved in any
such transaction are sold for use, con-
sumption, or resale within any place
under the jurisdiction of the United
States, and are not purchased by
schools, colleges, universities, public 1i-
braries, churches, hospitals, and chari-
table institutions not operated for
profit, as supplies for their own use;

(2) That nothing contained in this
section shall vrevent differentials
which make only due allowance for
differences in the cost of manufacture,
sale, or delivery resulting from the dif-
fering methods or quantities in which
such commodities are to such purchas-
ers sold or delivered;

Note: Cost justification under the above
proviso depends upon net savings in cost
based on all facts relevant to the transac-
tions under the terms of paragraph (a)(2) of
this section. For example, if a seller regular-
ly grants a discount based upon the pur-
chase of a specified quantity by a single
orcer for a single delivery, and this discount
is justified by cost differences, it does not
necessarily follow that the same discount
can be cost justified if granted to a purchas-
er of the same quantity by multiple orders
or for multiple deliveries.

(3) That nothing contained in this
section shall prevent persons engaged
in selling goods, wares, or merchandise
in commerce from selecting their own
customers in bona fide transactions
and not in restraint of trade;

(4) That nothing contained in this
paragraph shall prevent price changes
from time to time where made in re-
sponse to changing conditions affect-
ing the market for or the marketabil-
ity of the goods concerned, such as but
not limited to obsolescence of seasonal
goods, distress sales under court proc-
ess, or sales in good faith in discon-
tinuance of business in the goods con-
cerned;

(5) That nothing contained in this
section shall prevent the meeting in
good faith of an equally low price of a
competitor.

Nore: Subsection (b) of section 2 of the
Clayton Act, as amended, reads as follows:
“Upon proof being made, at any hearing on

355


§ 118.16

a complaint under this section, that there
has been discrimination in price or services
or facilities furnished, the burden of rebut-
ting the prima facie case thus made by
showing justification shall be upon the
person charged with a violation of this sec-
tion, and unless justification shall be affir-
matively shown, the Commission is author-
ized to issue an order terminating the dis-
crimination: Provided, however, That noth-
ing herein contained shall prevent a seller
rebutting the prima facie case thus made by
showing that his lower price or the furnish-
ing of services or facilities to any purchaser
or purchasers was made in good faith to
meet an equally low price of a competitor,
or the services or facilities furnished by a
competitor.”

(b) The following are examples of
price differential practices to be con-
sidered as subject to the prohibitions
of paragraph (a) of this section when
involving goods of like grade and qual-
ity which are sold for use, consump-
tion, or resale within any place under
the jurisdiction of the United States,
and which are not purchased by
schools, colleges, universities, public li-
braries, churches, hospitals, or chari-
table institutions not operated for
profit, as supplies for their own use,
and when:

(1) The commerce requirements
specified in paragraph (a) of this sec-
tion are present; and

(2) The price differential has a rea-
sonable probability of substantially
lessening competition or tending to
create a monopoly in any line of com-
merce, or of injuring, destroying, or
preventing competition with the in-
dustry member or with the customer
receiving the benefit of the price dif-
ferential, or with customers of either
of them; and

(3) The price differential is not justi-
fied by cost savings (see paragraph
(a)(2) of this section); and

(4) The price differential is not made
in response to changing conditiions af-
fecting the market for or the market-
ability of the goods concerned (see
paragraph (a)(4) of this section); and

(5) The lower price was not made to
meet in good faith an equally low
price of a competitor (see paragraph
(a)(5) of this section):

Example No. 1. At the end of a given
period an industry member grants a dis-
count to a customer equivalent to a fixed

Title 16—Commercial Practices

percentage of the total of the customer's
purchases during such period and fails to
grant a discount of the same percentage to
other customers on their purchases during
such period.

EXAMPLE No. 2. An industry member sells
goods to one or more of his customers at a
higher price than he charges other custom-
ers for like merchandise. It is immaterial
whether or not such discrimination is ac-
complished by misrepresentation as to the
grade and quality of the products sold.

(c) Prohibited brokerage and com-
missions. It is an unfair trade practice
for any member of the industry en-
gaged in commerce, in the course of
such commerce, to pay or grant, or to
receive or accept, anything of value as
a commission, brokerage, or other
compensation, or any allowance or dis-
count in lieu thereof, except for serv-
ices rendered in connection with the
sale or purchase of goods, wares or
merchandise, either to the other party
to such transaction or to an agent,
representative, or other intermediary
therein where such intermediary is
acting in fact for or in behalf, or is
subject to the direct or indirect con-
trol, of any party to such transaction
other than the person by whom such
compensation is so granted or paid.

(d) Prohibited advertising or promo-
tional allowances, etc. It is an unfair
trade practice for any member of the
industry engaged in commerce to pay
or contract for the payment of adver-
tising or promotional allowances or
any other thing of value to or for the
benefit of a customer of such member
in the course of such commerce as
compensation or in consideration for
any services or facilities furnished by
or through such customer in connec-
tion with the processing, handling,
sale, or offering for sale of any prod-
ucts or commodities manufactured,
sold, or offered for sale by such
member, unless such payment or con-
sideration is made known to and is
available on proportionally equal
terms to all other customers compet-
ing in the distribution of such prod-
ucts or commodities.

Nore 1: Industry members giving advertis-
ing allowances to competiing customers
must exercise precaution and diligence in
seeing that all of such allowances are used
in accordance with the terms of their offers.

356


Chapter I—Federal! Trade Commission

Nore 2: When an industry member gives
allowances to competing customers for ad-
vertising in a newspaper or periodical, the
fact that a lower advertising rate for equiva-
lent space is available to one or more, but
not all, such customers, is not to be regard-
ed by the industry member as warranting
the retention by such customer or custom-
ers of any portion of the allowance for his
or their personal use or benefit.

(e) Prohibited discriminatory serv-
ices or facilities. It is an unfair trade
practice for any member of the indus-
try engaged in commerce to discrimi-
nate in favor of one purchaser against
another purchaser or purchasers of a
commodity bought for resale, with or
without processing, by contracting to
furnish or furnishing, or by contribut-
ing to the furnishing of, any services
or facilities connected with the proc-
essing, handling, sale, or offering for
sale of such commodity so purchased
upon terms not accorded to all com-
peting purchasers on proportionally
equal terms.

Note: Subsection (b) of section 2 of the
Clayton Act, as amended, which is set forth
in the note concluding paragraph (a) of this
section is applicable to paragraph (e) of this
section.

(f)(1) The following is presented for
the purpose of clarifying the require-
ments of paragraphs (d) and (e) of this
section with respect to the supplying
of marketing services, facilities or
allowances by industry members to
their customers but it is not intended
to imply by such presentation that
other methods which assure of propor-
tional equality of treatment of com-
peting customers may not also be
used.

(2) An industry member may simul-
taneously offer to each of his custom-
ers competing in the resale of his
products the same kind of promotional
service, facility or allowance of a cost
value equal to a uniform percentage of
the sales (or purchases) of the indus-
try member’s products by each cus-
tomer during a specified and identical
period of time: Provided, however,
That when the service, facility or al-
lowance offered is of a type which
under reasonable terms and conditions
is not usable or suitable to the facili-
ties and business of all customers, and
is offered to any one customer, the
member offer each of those customers

§ 118.17

to whom the service, facility or allow-
ance is not usable or suitable an alter-
native type of promotional service, fa-
cility or allowance which is of equiva-
lent measurable cost, is usable by the
customer, and is suitable to his facili-
ties and business, and promptly
inform all competing customers of the
kind and amount of services, facilities
or allowances which he has offered to
each and the respective terms and con-
ditions under which such services,
facilities or allowances are to be fur-
nished by the industry member: And-
provided, further, That when the offer
of any service, facility or allowance to
any customer is conditioned on such
customer supplying some reciprocal
service, facility or payment, a recipro-
cal service, facility or payment be re-
quired in the offers to all other cus-
tomers and there be an equality of
ratio among all customers as to the
measurable cost of that which is sup-
plied by the industry member and the
reciprocal service, facility or payment
required by any customer. The indus-
try member must take every reason-
able precaution to see that services,
facilities or allowances which he fur-
nished to customers are used in accord
with the terms of his offer; and upon
failure of the customer to perform any
obligation on his part the industry
member must cease supplying the cus-
tomer any further service, facility or
allowance.

(g) Inducing or receiving an illegal
discrimination in price, advertising or
promotional allowances, or services or
Sacilities. It is an unfair trade practice
for any member of the industry en-
gaged in commerce, in the course of
such commerce, knowingly to induce
or receive a discrimination in price, ad-
vertising or promotional allowances, or
services or facilities, prohibited by the
foregoing provisions of this section.
(Rule 16]

$118.17 Aiding or abetting use of unfair
trade practices.

It is an unfair trade practice for any
person, firm, or corporation to aid,
abet, coerce, or induce another, direct-
ly or indirectly, to use or promote the
use of any unfair trade practice pro-
hibited by this part. [Rule 17]

PARTS 147-149 [RESERVED]